By Mike Miligi | Michael M Insurance Services Brightwaters, NY
If you’re turning 65, or you’re re-evaluating your coverage during Annual Enrollment, “Medicare Advantage” can sound like one simple thing. It isn’t. It’s a whole category of plans — different types, different networks, different costs, different extra benefits — and understanding the differences is what actually lets you choose well instead of guessing. This guide breaks all of it down.
Why Medicare Advantage Plans Are a Top Choice for Seniors Looking for Value
Medicare Advantage (also called Medicare Part C) plans are offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare. By law, they must cover everything Original Medicare covers — but most go considerably further:
- Lower or $0 monthly premiums. Many Medicare Advantage plans carry no additional monthly premium beyond what you already pay for Part B — something virtually impossible to find with a Medicare Supplement policy.
- A cap on your out-of-pocket spending. Original Medicare Part A and Part B have no annual out-of-pocket maximum — you pay 20% coinsurance on Part B services indefinitely. Medicare Advantage plans are required to cap your annual out-of-pocket costs (the federal maximum is $9,250 in 2026), which means your worst-case financial exposure is actually knowable. Catholic Health
- Extra benefits Original Medicare doesn’t offer at all , including dental, vision, hearing, and often prescription drug coverage bundled into a single plan.
- Built-in prescription drug coverage. Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D coverage, so you’re not managing a separate drug plan on top of your medical coverage.
That combination is a big part of why more than half of Medicare-eligible New Yorkers now choose Medicare Advantage over Original Medicare. For retirees on a fixed income, predictable costs and bundled benefits often matter more than unlimited nationwide provider access.
The trade-off is that Medicare Advantage plans use provider networks — so the value only holds up if your specific doctors and hospitals are actually covered by the plan you choose. That’s what the rest of this guide is for.
Understanding Medicare Advantage Plan Types
Not all Medicare Advantage plans work the same way. The plan type determines how much flexibility you have in choosing doctors, whether you need referrals, and how much you’ll pay for out-of-network care.
HMO (Health Maintenance Organization)
HMO plans require you to use doctors, specialists, and hospitals within the plan’s network, except in emergencies. You’ll typically need a referral from your primary care doctor to see a specialist. In exchange for this structure, HMO plans generally offer the lowest premiums and lowest cost-sharing of any Medicare Advantage plan type. HMOs work best if your care is consolidated within one network and you don’t mind the referral process.
PPO (Preferred Provider Organization)
PPO plans let you see any doctor who accepts Medicare, in-network or out-of-network, without a referral — though you’ll pay more for out-of-network care. This flexibility makes PPOs a strong fit if you split time between states, want the freedom to see specialists across different health systems, or simply don’t want to be locked into one network.
HMO-POS (HMO Point-of-Service)
An HMO-POS plan blends the two: it works like a standard HMO for most care, but adds limited flexibility to go out-of-network for certain services, usually at a higher cost. It’s a middle-ground option for people who want HMO-level pricing but occasional flexibility.
PFFS (Private Fee-for-Service)
PFFS plans determine how much they’ll pay providers and how much you’ll pay out-of-pocket on a service-by-service basis, rather than through a fixed network. These are less common today than they were a decade ago, but still exist in some markets.
Special Needs Plans (SNPs)
SNPs are a category of Medicare Advantage plan tailored to people with specific circumstances:
- Chronic Special Needs Plans (C-SNP) are limited to people with qualifying conditions like diabetes, End-Stage Renal Disease, HIV/AIDS, dementia, or chronic heart failure, and tailor benefits and drug formularies to those conditions.
- Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNP) are for people eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid, and can significantly reduce or eliminate your Medicare costs depending on your eligibility.
- Institutional Special Needs Plans (I-SNP) serve people who live in or require the level of care provided by a nursing facility.
Quick Reference: Local Hospital Network Status by Carrier (July 2026)
| Plan Type | Network Flexibility | Referrals Needed | Typical Premium | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HMO | Lowest — in-network only (except emergencies) | Usually yes | Lowest | Consolidated care within one network |
| PPO | Highest — in and out-of-network | No | Moderate | Travel, flexibility, multiple providers |
| HMO-POS | HMO with limited out-of-network option | Usually yes | Low–Moderate | Wanting some flexibility without full PPO cost |
| PFFS | Varies by provider agreement | No | Varies | Less common; check availability |
| SNP (C-SNP / D-SNP / I-SNP) | Varies, tailored to condition/eligibility | Varies | Often $0 for D-SNP | Qualifying chronic conditions, dual eligibility, or institutional care |
What a Medicare Advantage Plan Actually Costs
Understanding plan costs means looking past the premium alone:
Monthly premium: What you pay the carrier each month, separate from your Medicare Part B premium ($202/month in 2026 for most beneficiaries). Many plans offer this at $0.
Deductible : Some plans require you to pay a set amount before coverage kicks in for certain services, including a separate Part D prescription deductible on plans that include drug coverage.
Copays and coinsurance: Fixed amounts (copays) or percentages (coinsurance) you pay for specific services — doctor visits, specialist visits, hospital stays.
Maximum Out-of-Pocket (MOOP): The most you’ll pay out-of-pocket in a year for covered services. Once you hit this number, the plan covers 100% of covered costs for the rest of the year. For 2026, the federal maximum is $9,250(In Network), though individual plans can set a lower cap.
A plan with a slightly higher premium but a lower MOOP can end up costing significantly less over a year if you have ongoing health needs — which is why premium alone is a misleading way to compare plans.
Extra Benefits Beyond Original Medicare
This is where Medicare Advantage plans often earn their reputation for value. Depending on the plan, you may get:
- Dental coverage — routine cleanings, exams, and sometimes more extensive work like crowns or dentures .
- Hearing coverage — hearing exams and an allowance toward hearing aids
- Vision coverage — eye exams and an allowance toward glasses or contacts
- Over-the-counter (OTC) allowances — a quarterly credit toward health-related OTC products
- Transportation benefits — rides to medical appointments
- Fitness memberships — programs like SilverSneakers
- Meal delivery — often after a hospital discharge
Coverage and dollar amounts vary significantly by plan, so “does this plan cover dental” is really a question of degree, not yes-or-no.
Understanding CMS Star Ratings
Every year, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) rates Medicare Advantage plans on a 1-to-5 star scale based on quality measures and member satisfaction. A 1-star rating is considered poor; 5 stars is considered excellent. Plans rated 4 stars or higher are generally considered “top-rated.” It’s not the only factor in choosing a plan, but it’s a legitimate, independently-verified signal of plan quality worth weighing alongside cost and network.
When to Enroll
Timing affects both your options and whether you’ll face penalties:
- Initial Enrollment Period (IEP) : A seven-month window around your 65th birthday — three months before, your birthday month, and three months after. This is your first opportunity to enroll.
- Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) : October 15 – December 7 each year. Anyone on Medicare can review and change their coverage for the following year during this window.
- Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (MA OEP) : January 1 – March 31. If you’re already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan, you get one opportunity to switch plans or return to Original Medicare.
- Special Enrollment Period (SEP) : Available if you experience a qualifying life event — moving outside your plan’s service area, losing other coverage, or certain other circumstances.
- General Enrollment Period : January 1 – March 31, for those who missed their Initial Enrollment Period, typically with applicable penalties.
The Framework I Use With Every Client
Once you understand the plan types, costs, and enrollment windows above, here’s how I actually walk clients through choosing:
- It starts with Medications. You can change Doctors but not Meds so making sure they’re covered efficiently and at a reasonable cost is essential.
- Will your Doctors accept your plan ? Doctors are checked with each plan to make sure they are in network but a call to the office to verify their participation is always a good idea.
- Match the plan type to how you live. If you travel or split time out of state, a PPO’s flexibility may matter more than an HMO’s lower premium.
- Look at total cost, not just premium. Factor in deductibles, copays, and the MOOP together.
- Check the star rating as a quality gut-check alongside everything else.
- Confirm current network status for your specific address — not just general service-area availability.
2026 Medicare Advantage Plans Available in Bay Shore, NY (Suffolk County)
Putting the plan types above into practice, here’s every Medicare Advantage plan currently available at Bay Shore addresses: 27 plans, 8 with a $0 monthly premium, an average premium of $52.18/month for paid plans, and 9 plans rated 4 stars or higher.
| Plan Name | Type | Monthly Premium | Max Out-of-Poc ket | Rx Deductible | Star Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem Medicare Advantage 3 (HMO-POS) | HMO-P OS | $70.00 | $9,250 | $275 | 5.0 |
| Anthem Veteran 2 (HMO-POS) | HMO-P OS | N/A | $6,800 | N/A | 5.0 |
| Healthfirst Increased Benefits Plan (HMO) | HMO | $24.20 | $9,250 | $615 | 4.5 |
| Aetna Medicare Elite (PPO) | PPO | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 4.5 |
| Aetna Medicare Eagle Giveback (PPO) | PPO | N/A | $9,250 | N/A | 4.5 |
| Aetna Medicare Enhanced (PPO) | PPO | $134.00 | $6,750 | $615 | 4.5 |
| Aetna Medicare Elite Extra (PPO) | PPO | $54.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 4.5 |
| EmblemHealth VIP Gold (HMO) | HMO | $175.00 | $9,250 | $200 | 4.0 |
| EmblemHealth VIP Gold Plus (HMO) | HMO | $252.00 | $9,250 | $200 | 4.0 |
| VNS Health EasyCare (HMO) | HMO | $25.00 | $9,250 | $500 | 3.5 |
| Anthem Medicare Advantage (HMO) | HMO | $90.00 | $9,250 | $100 | 3.5 |
| Wellcare Simple Open (PPO) | PPO | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Giveback Open (PPO) | PPO | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Assist Open (PPO) | PPO | $58.80 | $9,250 | $530 | 3.0 |
| Aetna Medicare Enhanced (HMO) | HMO | $94.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Humana Gold Plus Giveback H3533-027 (HMO) | HMO | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Patriot Simple (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | N/A | $6,700 | N/A | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Assist (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | $51.40 | $9,250 | $590 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Simple (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Fidelis Assist (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | $32.50 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Fidelis Simple (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | $0.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Wellcare Fidelis Patriot Simple (HMO-POS) | HMO-POS | N/A | $9,250 | N/A | 3.0 |
| Humana USAA Honor Giveback (PPO) | PPO | N/A | $4,950 | N/A | 3.0 |
| HumanaChoice H5970-029 (PPO) | PPO | $32.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
| Humana Direct Choice Giveback (PPO) | PPO | $0.00 | $9,250 | $475 | 3.0 |
| HealthSpring True Choice (PPO) | PPO | $0.00 | $6,800 | $250 | 3.0 |
| Healthfirst Signature (PPO) | PPO | $55.00 | $9,250 | $615 | 3.0 |
Note: Several Wellcare, Wellcare Fidelis, and HealthSpring plans above are affected by 2026 Northwell Health network changes — see my related article on that topic for details before assuming any of these plans cover Southside Hospital or another Northwell facility.
Data reflects Bay Shore, NY (zip 11706) as of July 2026 and is subject to change — I verify current premiums, ratings, and network status directly before recommending anything to a client.
I’m Here To Help
I work with clients throughout western Suffolk County, including Islip , East Islip , Brightwaters , Deer Park , Babylon , and Sayville — and the plan types, cost structure, and enrollment timelines above apply the same way regardless of which of these towns you call home. What changes town to town is which specific plans are available and which networks include your providers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between an HMO and a PPO Medicare Advantage plan in Bay Shore?
An HMO requires in-network providers and usually a referral for specialists, in exchange for lower premiums. A PPO lets you see any Medicare-accepting provider, in or out of network, without a referral, usually at a higher cost for out-of-network care. Bay Shore residents have both types available — 15 HMO options and 12 PPO options among the current 27 plans.
How much does a Medicare Advantage plan cost in Bay Shore?
Every Bay Shore resident has access to at least one $0 monthly premium plan; 8 of the 27 available plans carry no premium. For those paying a premium, the average is $52.18/month, on top of your Part B premium.
What is a Special Needs Plan (SNP), and are any available in Bay Shore?
A Special Needs Plan is a type of Medicare Advantage plan tailored to a specific group — people with certain chronic conditions (C-SNP), people dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid (D-SNP), or people needing institutional-level care (I-SNP). Availability varies, so check current SNP options for your specific Bay Shore address.
Does Medicare Advantage cover dental, vision, and hearing in Bay Shore?
Many plans do, as an extra benefit beyond what Original Medicare covers — but coverage and dollar amounts vary significantly by plan, so it’s worth comparing specifics rather than assuming. If routine dental is a priority, I can point you to which Bay Shore plans offer the strongest coverage.
Does Medicare Advantage cover prescription drugs in Bay Shore?
Most Medicare Advantage plans available in Bay Shore include Part D prescription drug coverage bundled into the plan (called MAPD). A few plans do not include drug coverage, so it’s worth confirming before you enroll — especially if you’re currently on a standalone Part D plan.
When can I enroll in or switch a Medicare Advantage plan in Bay Shore?
You can enroll for the first time during your Initial Enrollment Period. You can switch plans during the Annual Enrollment Period (Oct 15 – Dec 7) or, if you’re already in a Medicare Advantage plan, during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (Jan 1 – Mar 31).
I'm about to turn 65 in Bay Shore — when should I start comparing plans?
Start about two to three months before your 65th birthday. Your Initial Enrollment Period actually opens three months before your birthday month, so getting an early start gives you time to check your doctors’ networks and compare formularies without rushing a decision.
Can I keep my Medicare Advantage plan if I move within Bay Shore or to a nearby Suffolk County town?
Medicare Advantage plan service areas are set by county, so a move within Suffolk County — say, from Bay Shore to Islip or Brightwaters — typically doesn’t require a plan change. A move to a different county could, so it’s worth confirming your new address against your plan’s service area either way.
Is Medicare Part C the same thing as Medicare Advantage?
Yes. “Medicare Advantage” and “Medicare Part C” refer to the same category of plans — private insurance alternatives to Original Medicare that are approved and regulated by CMS.
What's the average out-of-pocket maximum for Medicare Advantage plans in Bay Shore?
The average is $8,722.22 per year across currently available Bay Shore plans, though individual plans range from around $4,950 to the federal maximum of $9,250. This is the ceiling on what you’d pay for covered services in a given year — a number worth weighing alongside the premium.
Can veterans in Bay Shore have both VA benefits and a Medicare Advantage plan?
Yes, and the Department of Veterans Affairs actually encourages enrolling in Medicare as soon as you’re eligible, even if you have VA benefits. Having both means you’re covered for care outside the VA system, and it protects you from potential Part B and Part D late-enrollment penalties if your VA benefits ever change.
Does Medicare Advantage cover Southside Hospital in Bay Shore?
It depends on your carrier. Southside Hospital is part of Northwell Health, and as of mid-2026, Wellcare and Fidelis (including Wellcare By Fidelis) have both lost their Northwell contracts — see my related article on the 2026 Northwell network changes for the full details. Other carriers’ status should still be confirmed directly, since agreements can change
What about Good Samaritan Hospital in West Islip — is that a different network than Southside?
Yes. Good Samaritan University Hospital in West Islip is part of Catholic Health (Catholic Health Services of Long Island), a completely separate system from Northwell. I’m not aware of any reported network disputes affecting Good Samaritan the way Northwell has seen in 2026, but network status can still change, so it’s worth confirming directly for your specific plan rather than assuming
Is Zwanger-Pesiri Imaging in-network for most Medicare Advantage plans in Bay Shore?
don’t have confirmed, plan-by-plan data on this one, and I’d rather be straight with you than guess. Independent imaging centers like Zwanger-Pesiri often contract more broadly than hospital systems do, since they’re not tied to one system’s negotiations — but “often” isn’t the same as “confirmed for your plan.” If imaging at Zwanger-Pesiri matters to your decision, that’s exactly the kind of thing I verify directly before you enroll.
How do I know which Medicare Advantage plan actually covers my doctor in Bay Shore?
That’s exactly what I do for every client — I verify current network status directly rather than relying on a plan’s general marketing materials or an online search tool alone.
Do you help residents outside of Bay Shore too?
Yes — I regularly work with clients in Islip, East Islip, Deer Park, Brightwaters, Babylon, and Sayville as well.
I'm Here to Help
I’ve been helping Bay Shore-area residents navigate Medicare for over 10 years. I am a Medicare Beneficiary myself so I understand firsthand the choices available in our area. If you’re unsure whether your plan still covers your hospital, or you’re trying to decide between a Medicare Advantage plan and a Medicare Supplement, call me. I’ll look at your specific circumstances, your plan, and help you with your options. That conversation is always free
I work with clients throughout western Suffolk County, including Islip , East Islip , Brightwaters , Deer Park , Babylon , and Sayville — and the plan types, cost structure, and enrollment timelines above apply the same way regardless of which of these towns you call home.
Related Topics
Info Sources-
Brightwaters, NY
631-774-3786
mmilinsurance@gmail.com
www.mymedicaremike.com
Related Articles
Medicare Advantage Plans Explained: Is a Medicare Advantage Plan a Good Fit for You in 2026?
Key Takeaways 1. A Medicare Advantage Plan (Part C) replaces Original Medicare and combines hospital, medical, and often prescription drug coverage into one plan. 2.
10 Questions People Ask Before Signing Up for Medicare
What Are People Asking? ● Is Medicare free at 65? ● How much does Medicare cost per month? ● Do I apply for Medicare through
Is A Medicare Advantage Plan A Good Fit For Me?
What Are People Asking? ● “What if I want Dental and Vision coverage?” ● “What if I want a low or $0 monthly premium?” ●
